Skip to main content

Table 2 List of some common calibration parameters

From: Magnetometer data from the GRACE satellite duo

  

2008–2017

2008–2012

2013–2017

\(i = 1\)

\(i = 2\)

\(i = 3\)

\(i = 1\)

\(i = 2\)

\(i = 3\)

\(i = 1\)

\(i = 2\)

\(i = 3\)

GRACE-A

\(b_{\text {SA1},i}\ [\text {nT/mA}]\)

2.77

0.86

3.57

2.41

\(-\,1.13\)

2.81

1.42

3.31

5.18

\(b_{\text {SA2},i}\ [\text {nT/mA}]\)

1.71

\(-\,2.33\)

9.61

2.34

0.64

4.68

1.30

\(-\,2.33\)

19.81

\(b_{\text {Batt},i}\ [\text {nT/mA}]\)

\(-\,0.87\)

1.27

\(-\,3.41\)

\(-\,1.03\)

1.94

\(-\,2.68\)

0.64

\(-\,0.32\)

\(-\,5.25\)

\(b_{\text {ADC},i}\ [\text {nT}]\)

3.65

0.17

0.08

3.75

0.08

0.14

3.11

0.27

0.05

\(M_{1,i}\ [\text {nT/mA}]\)

\(-\,3.060\)

37.573

\(-\,36.994\)

\(-\,3.059\)

37.549

\(-\,36.943\)

\(-\,3.061\)

37.595

\(-\,37.042\)

\(M_{2,i}\ [\text {nT/mA}]\)

2.715

5.044

1.328

2.723

5.045

1.323

2.706

5.045

1.329

\(M_{3,i}\ [\text {nT/mA}]\)

22.159

0.706

\(-\,2.576\)

22.134

0.715

\(-\,2.592\)

22.188

0.701

\(-\,2.565\)

\(\xi _{11}^i\)

\(-\,0.07\)

0.05

\(-\,0.20\)

\(-\,0.02\)

0.09

\(-\,0.09\)

\(-\,0.09\)

0.10

\(-\,0.36\)

\(\xi _{22}^i\)

\(-\,2.67\)

\(-\,1.90\)

\(-\,2.18\)

\(-\,3.99\)

\(-\,3.67\)

\(-\,0.84\)

\(-\,1.49\)

1.15

\(-\,3.88\)

\(\xi _{33}^i\)

0.29

\(-\,0.15\)

0.35

0.33

\(-\,0.12\)

0.40

0.26

\(-\,0.13\)

0.27

\(\xi _{12}^i\)

0.82

0.55

5.09

0.90

0.88

5.04

0.70

0.43

5.13

\(\xi _{13}^i\)

\(-\,0.07\)

\(-\,7.06\)

\(-\,0.17\)

\(-\,0.17\)

\(-\,7.18\)

\(-\,0.10\)

0.10

\(-\,6.88\)

\(-\,0.26\)

\(\xi _{23}^i\)

2.08

\(-\,0.01\)

\(-\,0.22\)

2.11

\(-\,0.19\)

0.15

2.02

0.28

\(-\,0.69\)

\(\eta _{111}^i\)

0.26

\(-\,0.61\)

0.04

0.23

\(-\,0.66\)

\(-\,0.04\)

0.28

\(-\,0.59\)

0.11

\(\eta _{222}^i\)

\(-\,1.58\)

\(-\,2.02\)

0.62

\(-\,2.19\)

\(-\,1.10\)

0.28

\(-\,1.07\)

\(-\,3.12\)

1.15

\(\eta _{333}^i\)

0.08

\(-\,0.01\)

\(-\,0.03\)

0.11

\(-\,0.00\)

\(-\,0.02\)

0.05

\(-\,0.00\)

\(-\,0.04\)

\(\eta _{112}^i\)

\(-\,0.41\)

0.99

0.67

\(-\,0.68\)

1.31

0.14

\(-\,0.10\)

0.79

1.25

\(\eta _{113}^i\)

\(-\,0.01\)

\(-\,0.15\)

\(-\,0.08\)

\(-\,0.01\)

\(-\,0.13\)

\(-\,0.09\)

\(-\,0.02\)

\(-\,0.16\)

\(-\,0.08\)

\(\eta _{223}^i\)

0.20

0.69

\(-\,0.29\)

0.29

0.80

\(-\,0.14\)

0.14

0.68

\(-\,0.48\)

\(\eta _{122}^i\)

0.18

\(-\,0.15\)

\(-\,0.01\)

0.19

\(-\,0.12\)

\(-\,0.01\)

0.18

\(-\,0.18\)

0.01

\(\eta _{133}^i\)

0.25

0.01

\(-\,0.14\)

0.39

\(-\,0.02\)

\(-\,0.09\)

0.09

0.07

\(-\,0.19\)

\(\eta _{233}^i\)

\(-\,0.12\)

0.25

\(-\,0.43\)

\(-\,0.08\)

\(-\,0.25\)

0.29

\(-\,0.15\)

1.08

\(-\,1.34\)

\(\eta _{123}^i\)

0.11

\(-\,0.27\)

\(-\,0.23\)

\(-\,0.02\)

\(-\,0.30\)

\(-\,0.16\)

0.25

\(-\,0.25\)

\(-\,0.34\)

GRACE-B

\(b_{\text {SA1},i}\ [\text {nT/mA}]\)

1.03

\(-\,3.20\)

4.77

1.81

\(-\,1.09\)

1.97

1.12

\(-\,4.05\)

5.14

\(b_{\text {SA2},i}\ [\text {nT/mA}]\)

2.61

3.66

8.41

4.02

\(-\,0.52\)

4.71

1.15

9.13

10.98

\(b_{\text {Batt},i}\ [\text {nT/mA}]\)

\(-\,0.15\)

2.01

\(-\,3.88\)

\(-\,0.81\)

1.21

\(-\,1.65\)

\(-\,0.20\)

1.81

\(-\,3.88\)

\(b_{\text {ADC},i}\ [\text {nT}]\)

2.93

0.10

0.22

2.76

0.24

0.05

2.72

\(-\,0.19\)

0.43

\(M_{1,i}\ [\text {nT/mA}]\)

\(-\,1.629\)

36.947

\(-\,36.401\)

\(-\,1.621\)

36.866

\(-\,36.262\)

\(-\,1.636\)

37.040

\(-\,36.552\)

\(M_{2,i}\ [\text {nT/mA}]\)

2.718

5.047

1.350

2.717

5.053

1.356

2.719

5.044

1.347

\(M_{3,i}\ [\text {nT/mA}]\)

22.614

0.875

\(-\,2.046\)

22.576

0.873

\(-\,2.050\)

22.666

0.874

\(-\,2.047\)

\(\xi _{11}^i\)

\(-\,0.23\)

0.47

0.20

\(-\,0.25\)

0.50

0.16

\(-\,0.29\)

0.47

0.19

\(\xi _{22}^i\)

\(-\,1.15\)

\(-\,0.71\)

1.22

\(-\,1.07\)

3.94

\(-\,0.99\)

\(-\,1.02\)

\(-\,3.83\)

4.70

\(\xi _{33}^i\)

0.26

0.23

0.38

0.25

0.19

0.42

0.23

0.29

0.32

\(\xi _{12}^i\)

\(-\,0.24\)

0.25

4.81

\(-\,0.62\)

0.15

5.07

0.23

0.52

4.49

\(\xi _{13}^i\)

\(-\,0.06\)

\(-\,6.89\)

0.17

\(-\,0.07\)

\(-\,6.91\)

0.09

\(-\,0.03\)

\(-\,6.80\)

0.32

\(\xi _{23}^i\)

1.99

\(-\,0.45\)

\(-\,0.02\)

1.85

0.11

\(-\,0.25\)

2.17

\(-\,0.82\)

0.34

\(\eta _{111}^i\)

0.10

\(-\,0.63\)

0.22

0.07

\(-\,0.63\)

0.32

0.11

\(-\,0.62\)

0.09

\(\eta _{222}^i\)

\(-\,0.35\)

\(-\,0.29\)

0.49

\(-\,0.89\)

0.90

\(-\,0.61\)

0.23

\(-\,1.30\)

1.50

\(\eta _{333}^i\)

\(-\,0.02\)

0.03

\(-\,0.06\)

\(-\,0.05\)

\(-\,0.00\)

\(-\,0.05\)

\(-\,0.00\)

0.06

\(-\,0.05\)

\(\eta _{112}^i\)

\(-\,0.72\)

0.95

\(-\,0.37\)

\(-\,0.82\)

0.98

0.10

\(-\,0.52\)

1.22

\(-\,0.77\)

\(\eta _{113}^i\)

0.02

\(-\,0.17\)

0.03

0.01

\(-\,0.14\)

0.03

0.04

\(-\,0.19\)

0.04

\(\eta _{223}^i\)

0.81

0.37

\(-\,0.02\)

0.74

0.60

\(-\,0.33\)

0.93

0.24

0.06

\(\eta _{122}^i\)

0.24

\(-\,0.20\)

\(-\,0.02\)

0.27

\(-\,0.15\)

\(-\,0.09\)

0.23

\(-\,0.23\)

0.05

\(\eta _{133}^i\)

\(-\,0.09\)

0.07

\(-\,0.18\)

\(-\,0.21\)

0.08

\(-\,0.15\)

0.05

0.06

\(-\,0.21\)

\(\eta _{233}^i\)

\(\,0.65\)

\(-\,0.17\)

0.05

\(-\,0.84\)

0.65

0.02

\(-\,0.48\)

\(-\,0.51\)

0.14

\(\eta _{123}^i\)

\(-\,0.18\)

0.12

\(-\,0.13\)

\(-\,0.08\)

0.17

\(-\,0.11\)

\(-\,0.28\)

0.10

\(-\,0.16\)

  1. Numbers listed in the left panel labelled “2008–2017” are estimated from the entire data set, while those in the middle and right panels are determined from data subsets spanning its first and last part, respectively