- Open Access
High-accuracy statistical simulation of planetary accretion: I. Test of the accuracy by comparison with the solution to the stochastic coagulation equation
Earth, Planets and Space volume 51, pages205–217(1999)
The object of this series of studies is to develop a highly accurate statistical code for describing the planetary accumulation process. In the present paper, as a first step, we check the validity of the method proposed by Wetherill and Stewart (1989) by comparing the results obtained by their method with the analytical solution to the stochastic coagulation equation (or to a well-evaluated numerical solution). As the collisional probability Ai j between bodies with masses of im1 and jm1 (m1 being the unit mass), we consider the two cases: one is Ai j∝ i × j and another is Ai j ∝ min(i, j )(i 1/3 + j1/3)(i + j ). In both cases, it is known that runaway growth occurs. The latter case corresponds to a simplified model of the planetesimal accumulation. We assumed that a collision of two bodies leads to their coalescence. Wetherill and Stewart’s method contains some parameters controlling the practical numerical computation. Among these, two parameters are important: the mass division parameter δ, which determines the mass ratio of the adjacent mass batches, and the time division parameter ∈, which controls the size of a time step in numerical integration. Through a number of numerical simulations for the case of Ai j = i × j, we find that when δ ≤ 1.6 and ∈ ≤ 0.03 the numerical simulation can reproduce the analytical solution within a certain level of accuracy independently of the size of the body system. For the case of the planetesimal accumulation, it is shown that the simulation with δ ≤ 1.3 and ∈ ≤ 0.04 can describe precisely runaway growth. Because the accumulation process is stochastic, in order to obtain reliable mean values it is necessary to take the ensemble mean of the numerical results obtained with different random number generators. It is also found that the number of simulations, Nc, demanded to obtain the reliable mean value is about 500 and does not strongly depend on the functional form of Ai j. From the viewpoint of the numerical handling, the above value of δ(≤ 1.3) and Nc(∼500) are reasonable and, hence, we conclude that the numerical method proposed by Wetherill and Stewart is a valid and useful method for describing the planetary accumulation process. The real planetary accumulation process is more complex since it is coupled with the velocity evolution of the planetesimals. In the subsequent paper, we will complete the high-accuracy statistical code which simulate the accumulation process coupled with the velocity evolution and test the accuracy of the code by comparing with the results of N -body simulation.
Aarseth, S. J., D. N. C. Lin, and P. L. Palmer, Evolution of planetesimals. II. Numerical simulations, Astrophys. J., 403, 351–376, 1993.
Barge, P. and R. Pellat, Mass spectrum and velocity dispersions during planetesimal accumulation. I. Accretion, Icarus, 93, 270–287, 1991.
Bayewitz, M. H., J. Yerushalmi, S. Katz, and R. Shinnar, The extent of correlations in a stochastic coalescence process, J. Atmos. Sci., 31, 1604–1614, 1974.
Beaugé, C. and S. J. Aarseth, N-body simulation of planetary formation, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 245, 30–39, 1990.
Greenberg, R., J. Wacker, C. R. Chapman, and W. K. Hartmann, Planetesimals to planets: Numerical simulation of collisional evolution, Icarus, 35, 1–26, 1978.
Greenzweig, Y. and J. J. Lissauer, Accretion rates of protoplanets II. Gaussian distributions of planetesimal velocities, Icarus, 100, 440–463, 1992.
Hayashi, C., K. Nakazawa, and Y. Nakagawa, Formation of the solar system, in Protostars and Planets II, edited by D. C. Black and M. S. Matthews, 1100 pp., Univ. of Arizona Press, Tucson, 1985.
Kokubo, E. and S. Ida, On runaway growth of planetesimals, Icarus, 123, 180–191, 1996.
Kokubo, E. and S. Ida, Formation of protoplanets from planetesimals in the solar nebula, Icarus, 1998 (submitted).
Lecar, M. and S. J. Aarseth, A numerical simulation of the formation of the terrestrial planets, Astrophys. J., 305, 564–579, 1986.
Lushnikov, A. A., Coagulation in finite systems, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 65, 276–285, 1978.
Makino, J., T. Fukushige, Y. Funato, and E. Kokubo, On the mass distribution of planetesimals in the early runaway stage, New Astronomy, 3, 411–416, 1998.
Marcus, A. H., Stochastic coalescence, Technometrics, 10, 133–143, 1968.
Nakagawa, Y., C. Hayashi, and K. Nakazawa, Accumulation of planetesimals in the solar nebula, Icarus, 54, 361–376, 1983.
Ohtsuki, K., Y. Nakagawa, and K. Nakazawa, Growth of the earth in nebula gas, Icarus, 75, 552–565, 1988.
Safronov, V. S., Evolution of the Protoplanetary Cloud and Formation of the Earth and Planets, Nauka, Moscow, 1969 (Transl. 1972 NASA TT F-677).
Smoluchowski, M. V., Drei vortrage uber diffusion, brownshe molekularbe-wegung und koagulation von kolloidteilchen, Phys. Zeits., 17, 557–571; 585–599, 1916.
Spaute, D., S. J. Weidenschilling, D. R. Davis, and F. Marzari, Accretional evolution of a planetesimal swarm: 1. A new simulation, Icarus, 92, 147–164, 1991.
Stewart, G. R. and S. Ida, Velocity evolution of planetesimals: Unified analytical formulae and comparison with N-body simulations, Icarus, 1998 (submitted).
Tanaka, H. and K. Nakazawa, Stochastic coagulation equation and validity of the statistical coagulation equation, J. Geomag. Geoelectr., 45, 361–381, 1993.
Tanaka, H. and K. Nakazawa, Validity of the statistical coagulation equation and runaway growth of protoplanets, Icarus, 107, 404–412, 1994.
Trubnikov, B. A., Solution of the coagulation equations in the case of bilinear coefficient of adhesion of particles, Sov. Phys. Dokl., 16, 124–126, 1971.
Wetherill, G. W., Comparison of analytical and physical modeling of planetesimal accumulation, Icarus, 88, 336–354, 1990.
Wetherill, G. W. and G. R. Stewart, Accumulation of a swarm of small planetesimals, Icarus, 77, 330–357, 1989.
Wetherill, G. W. and G. R. Stewart, Formation of planetary embryos: Effects of fragmentation, low relative velocity, and independent variation of eccentricity and inclination, Icarus, 106, 190–209, 1993.
About this article
Cite this article
Inaba, S., Tanaka, H., Ohtsuki, K. et al. High-accuracy statistical simulation of planetary accretion: I. Test of the accuracy by comparison with the solution to the stochastic coagulation equation. Earth Planet Sp 51, 205–217 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1186/BF03352224
- Accumulation Process
- Statistical Code
- Smoluchowski Equation
- Ensemble Means
- Coagulation Equation