Simulation of heterogeneity sections obtained by neutrino radiography
© The Society of Geomagnetism and Earth, Planetary and Space Sciences (SGEPSS); The Seismological Society of Japan; The Volcanological Society of Japan; The Geodetic Society of Japan; The Japanese Society for Planetary Sciences; TERRAPUB 2010
Received: 18 November 2008
Accepted: 1 May 2009
Published: 22 February 2010
Heterogeneity sections potentially observed by neutrino radiography are simulated by using S-velocity tomography models. All of the velocity heterogeneities in these models are assumed to be of thermal origin, and the velocity anomalies are translated into density anomalies by using the scaling relations obtained from previous laboratory experiments. Assuming the use of the IceCube Neutrino Detector, the density anomalies were integrated along the paths to this detector. Five tomography models were tested, but the obtained sections show common features: paths sampling the CMB region beneath Africa and paths sampling the root of East Antarctica are anomalous. Previous studies suggested that these two regions may be chemically distinct. Approximate order estimations suggest that if these regions have 10% density anomalies, IceCube will detect them in about 300 years.
In the past two decades, the resolution and accuracy of seismic tomography models have been greatly improved, and there is now a consensus on the larger-scale patterns of velocity heterogeneities in the mantle (e.g., Romanowicz, 2003). However, because various types of origins (thermal and/or chemical) can explain the observed velocity heterogeneities, it is not possible to ascertain whether heterogeneous regions are buoyant or not. This is one of the most important obstacles to a good understanding of geodynamics.
Although density heterogeneities can be constrained by seismic tomography (e.g., Ishii and Tromp, 1999), the reliability of the obtained models is still controversial (e.g., Resovsky and Ritzwoller, 1999; Romanowicz, 2001). It is therefore important to have independent constraints on the density structure. A highly sensitive neutrino telescope, the IceCube Neutrino Detector (Ahrens et al., 2004; Achterberg et al., 2006), is now under construction at the South Pole. Neutrino radiography (e.g., Volkova and Zatsepin, 1974; Wilson, 1984) using this detector should prove to be one of the most promising tools for producing independent constraints on the density heterogeneities in the Earth.
The idea of neutrino radiography is straightforward. The Earth becomes partly opaque for VHE neutrinos with energy greater than a few TeV. Neutrino radiography can deduce the Earth’s density structure from the number of neutrino-induced muon events, which can be collected by a kilometer-scale neutrino telescope, e.g., the IceCube. Several studies have proposed projects to constrain radial density structures with sufficient statistical significance by using either atmospheric neutrinos (e.g., Gonzalez-Garcia et al., 2008) or extraterrestrial neutrinos (e.g., Kuo et al., 1995). Because seismic density models still have uncertainties even in the radial structures (e.g., Kennett, 1998), such constraints are important.
In contrast, I focus here on the detection of laterally heterogeneous density structures. Although detection might not be very easy, it would be useful to estimate which heterogeneities can potentially be observed and what obstacles there are in detecting them. In this study, I simulate the heterogeneity sections under the assumption that all of the velocity heterogeneities are of thermal origin. If the consistency or inconsistency can be confirmed between observed and simulated sections in the future, constraints could be provided on the chemical structures in the Earth. Although the main focus of this study is to show possibly observable chemical heterogeneities, the detectability of these heterogeneities is also discussed.
To simulate heterogeneity sections, density structure models are needed. Density structure models are required in some geophysical applications, such as geodynamic modeling (e.g., Hager et al., 1985). In such applications, because of uncertainties in the available density structure models, the density heterogeneities have often been derived by scaling (multiplying some constants as functions of depth) the velocity heterogeneities in tomography models. I have followed this procedure here.
2.1 Tomography models used
Although a wide variety of models exist, they can be classified into two main categories: those obtained by using short-period data (hereafter referred to as short-wavelength models) and those obtained using broadband data (referred to as long-wavelength models). The short-wavelength models are generally obtained using travel time data of body wave phases. Because of the accuracy of phase identification and picking, the initial P travel times are the most extensively used, and most short-wavelength models are P models. These models have a strong ability to resolve fine structures and have succeeded in revealing, for example, the fates of subducting slabs (e.g., Fukao et al., 1992; van der Hilst et al., 1997). Although efforts have been made to utilize later phases, the quality and quantity of their travel time data have been poor. As a result, most of the models obtained thus far suffer from strongly inhomogeneous data sampling and are relatively weak in constraining global patterns of velocity heterogeneities.
The long-wavelength models are generally obtained by using higher-quality waveform data. Because of the higher sensitivity of surface waveforms to the S-velocity structure and the well-isolated later body wave phases in the transverse component of body waveforms, most longwavelength models are S models. Secondary data (such as body wave travel times, phase velocity of surface waves, and splitting functions of free oscillation modes) are frequently extracted from the waveforms and are inverted (e.g., Ritsema et al., 1999; Masters et al., 2000; Grand, 2002; Montelli et al., 2004). To fully exploit information included in the waveform data, a waveform inversion (e.g., Mégnin and Romanowicz, 2000; Panning and Romanowicz, 2006; Takeuchi, 2007) or a joint inversion of the secondary data and waveform data (e.g., Gu et al., 2001, 2003) is conducted. These procedures are strong in their ability to resolve the long-wavelength features of global lateral heterogeneities but are relatively weak in their ability to resolve fine structures.
The purpose of this study is to simulate the overall pattern of heterogeneities that can be expected to be observed by the IceCube. I therefore focused on the longwavelength models. Since the simulated patterns might be biased by uncertainties in the tomography models used, I tested and compared the results of five models: SH18CE (Takeuchi, 2007), SAW24B16 (Mégnin and Romanowicz, 2000), SB4L18 (Masters et al., 2000), S20RTS (Ritsema et al., 1999), and S362D1 (Gu et al., 2001). All are S-velocity models obtained by using broadband waveform data.
2.2 Scaling relations used
There is also a wide range of options in choosing scaling relations. Two types of scaling relations are available: those obtained by laboratory experiments (e.g., Karato, 1993) and those obtained by the inversion of geophysical data (e.g., Forte et al., 1994; Ishii and Tromp, 2001). The former are for heterogeneities caused by the assumed origin (e.g., thermal origin), whereas the latter are for heterogeneities in the actual Earth. Because the purpose of this study is to simulate the expected patterns when all of the heterogeneities in the Earth are assumed to be of thermal origin, I focused on the laboratory experiments.
The lower-velocity anomalies beneath Africa are suggested even by the early tomography models (e.g., Dziewonski, 1984). Their detailed structures have been studied extensively using regional array data (e.g., Ritsema et al., 1998; Ni et al., 2002, 2005; Ni and Helmberger, 2003). The results suggested that the volume of this anomalous body is large (about 1300 km high, 1200 km across, and 7000 km long), and that the velocity anomalies inside the body are strong (about a 3% velocity reduction throughout this body).
The higher-velocity anomalies beneath East Antarctica are also suggested by the earlier tomography models (e.g., Montagner and Tanimoto, 1991). The feature is independently confirmed by regional analyses (e.g., Ritzwoller et al., 2001; Kobayashi and Zhao, 2004), although the suggested depth extent of this anomalous body is somewhat inconsistent among studies.
In neutrino radiography, we observe the integrated density anomalies along the paths. The effects of heterogeneities at the central points might not be observed because of cancellation by positive and negative anomalies on the path. We therefore show “integrated cross sections” (the integrated density anomalies along the paths; Fig. 2), which are directly related to the observations by the neutrino detector.
4.1 Possibly detectable chemical heterogeneities
In these simulations, I (1) used velocity heterogeneities in tomography models and (2) translated the velocity anomalies into density anomalies. Of course, both of these processes have uncertainties. However, uncertainty in tomography models appears not to change the overall patterns of the simulated sections, as shown in Fig. 4. Therefore, when we observed inconsistency between the observed and simulated patterns in the overall features, it was likely due to uncertainties in the latter procedure.
In this study, I scaled the velocity anomalies to the density anomalies under the assumption that velocity heterogeneities are all of thermal origin. The predominance of thermal origin is often presumed partly due to the similarity between the observed geoid data and the geoid pattern simulated under this assumption (e.g., Hager et al., 1985). However, the existence of chemical heterogeneities is suggested in several regions, including the two regions focused on here.
The low-velocity provinces in the CMB region (beneath Africa and the Pacific) are considered to be chemically distinct. The regions are suggested to have sharp sides (e.g., Ni et al., 2002; To et al., 2005; Takeuchi et al., 2008), which are not likely to be due to purely thermal anomalies. The regions are also suggested to have an anti-correlation between the shear and bulk sound velocity anomalies by both global tomography (e.g., Ishii and Tromp, 1999; Masters et al., 2000) and regional array analyses (e.g., Wang and Wen, 2007); this anti-correlation is also difficult to explain by thermal anomalies. Two popular scenarios for the chemical distinction are the enrichment of iron obtained via interactions with the iron core and the accumulation of piles of dense materials at the bottom of the mantle upwellings. If either of these scenarios occur, we expect higher-density anomalies, which is the opposite of what would be expected from thermal origin.
The high-velocity regions beneath older continents are also considered to be chemically distinct. Almost every older continent appears to have a high-velocity root about 200–400 km thick. These regions are called the continental tectosphere, which is considered to be buoyant compared with the ambient mantle because of the depletion of a basalt-like component (e.g., Jordan, 1975, 1978). The regions are thus considered to have lower-density anomalies; this is also opposite of what would be expected from thermal anomalies.
When we assume that all heterogeneities are of thermal origin, we expect the heterogeneity patterns shown in Fig. 4. However, if the two regions of focus are in fact chemically distinct, we should expect anomalies with opposite signs. If we could observe the signs of these integrated density anomalies, we can possibly constrain the chemical heterogeneities in these two regions.
4.2 Detectability of the focused features
I will now estimate how realistic it is to detect the focused chemical heterogeneities. The purpose of the estimation is to see the order of the required amount of data. Rigorous statistical evaluations are beyond the scope of this paper.
Following the method of GG08, I do not include the events in the most horizontal bin, cos θ > −0.17, to avoid contaminations by backgrounds from possible remaining misreconstructed downgoing muons. I use the simulated results shown in table 1 in GG08 as N i in Eq. (4). I chose here σcc (Ē v ) = 16.5 × 10−35 cm2 to reproduce the resultant rejection power χ2 = 4.72 which was obtained by GG08. Using these assumptions and explicit values, we simulate R and R′ as a function of a zenith angle (Fig. 5(c) and (d)). Figure 5(c) shows that the results by this approximated method well agree with those by the rigorous method in Gonzalez-Garcia et al. (2008; figure 2, center). Figure 5(d) shows that, for the problem in this study, I can expect 0.1–0.5% perturbations in the detected event numbers for each angular bin. The computed rejection power is χ′2 = 0.192, which suggests that, to obtain 1σ signals, we should improve fivefold in the S/N ratio. I therefore need about 30 times the amount of data, which suggests that we require about 300 years of observations. Of course, these quantities depend on the amplitudes of the density perturbations assumed in ρ3D. For example, if we assume 30% density anomalies, the required observation periods will be about 30 years.
- Achterberg, A., M. Ackermann, J. Adams et al., First year performance of the IceCube neutrino telescope, Astropart. Phys., 26, 155–173, 2006.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ahrens, J., J. N. Bahcall, X. Bai et al., Sensitivity of the IceCube detector to astrophysical sources of high energy muon neutrinos, Astropart. Phys., 20, 507–532, 2004.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Dziewonski, A. M., Mapping the lower mantle: determination of lateral heterogeneity in P velocity up to degree and order 6, J. Geophys. Res., 89, 5929–5952, 1984.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Dziewonski, A. M. and D. L. Anderson, Preliminary Reference Earth Model, Phys. Earth Planet. Inter., 25, 297–356, 1981.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Forte, A. M., R. L. Woodward, and A. M. Dziewonski, Joint inversions of seismic and geodynamic data for models of three-dimensional mantle heterogeneity, J. Geophys. Res., 99, 21,857–21,877, 1994.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Fukao, Y., M. Obayashi, H. Inoue, and M. Nenbai, Subducting slabs stagnant in the mantle transition zone, J. Geophys. Res., 97, 4809–4822, 1992.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gonzalez-Garcia, M. C., F. Halzen, M. Maltoni, and H. K. M. Tanaka, Radiography of Earth’s core and mantle with atmospheric neutrinos, Phys. Rev. Lett., 100, 061802, 2008.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Grand, S. P., Mantle shear-wave tomography and the fate of subducted slabs, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A, 360, 2475–2491, 2002.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gu, Y. J., A. M. Dziewonski, W.-J. Su, and G. Ekstrøm, Models of the mantle shear velocity and discontinuities in the pattern of lateral heterogeneities, J. Geophys. Res., 106, 11,169–11,199, 2001.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gu, Y. J., A. M. Dziewonski, and G. Ekstrøm, Simultaneous inversion for mantle shear velocity and topography of transition zone discontinuities, Geophys. J. Int., 154, 559–583, 2003.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hager, B. H., R. W. Clayton, M. A. Richards, R. P. Comer, and A. M. Dziewonski, Lower mantle heterogeneity, dynamic topography and the geoid, Nature, 313, 541–545, 1985.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ishii, M. and J. Tromp, Normal-mode and free-air gravity constraints on lateral variations in velocity and density of Earth’s mantle, Science, 285, 1231–1236, 1999.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ishii, M. and J. Tromp, Even-degree lateral variations in the Earth’s mantle constrained by free oscillations and the free-air gravity anomaly, Geophys. J. Int., 145, 77–96, 2001.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jordan, T., The continental tectosphere, Rev. Geophys., 13, 1–12, 1975.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jordan, T., Composition and development of the continental tectosphere, Nature, 274, 544–548, 1978.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Karato, S., Importance of anelasticity in the interpretation of seismic tomography, Geophys. Res. Lett., 20, 1623–1626, 1993.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kennett, B. L. N., On the density distribution within the Earth, Geophys. J. Int., 132, 374–382, 1998.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kobayashi, R. and D. Zhao, Rayleigh-wave group velocity distribution in the Antarctic region, Phys. Earth Planet. Inter., 141, 167–181, 2004.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kuo, C., H. J. Crawford, R. Jeanloz, B. Romanowicz, G. Shapiro, and M. L. Stevenson, Extraterrestrial neutrinos and Earth structure, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 133, 95–103, 1995.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Masters, G., G. Laske, H. Bolton, and A. Dziewonski, The relative behavior of shear velocity, bulk sound speed, and compressional velocity in the mantle: Implications for chemical and thermal structure, in Earth’s Deep Interior: Mineral Physics and Tomography From the Atomic to the Global Scale, edited by Karato, S., A. M. Forte, R. C. Liebermann, G. Masters, and L. Stixrude, pp. 63–87, American Geophysical Union, Washington D.C., 2000.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Mégnin, C. and B. Romanowicz, The three-dimensional shear velocity structure of the mantle from the inversion of body, surface and highermode waveforms, Geophys. J. Int., 143, 709–728, 2000.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Montagner, J. P. and T. Tanimoto, Global upper mantle tomography of seismic velocities and anisotropies, J. Geophys. Res., 96, 20,337–20,351, 1991.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Montelli, R., G. Nolet, F. A. Dahlen, G. Masters, E. R. Engdahl, and S. H. Hung, Finite-frequency tomography reveals a variety of plumes in the mantle, Science, 303, 338–343, 2004.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ni, S. and D. V. Helmberger, Ridge-like lower mantle structure beneath South Africa, J. Geophys. Res., 108, 2094, doi:10.1029/2001JB001545, 2003.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ni, S., E. Tan, M. Gurnis, and D. V. Helmberger, Sharp sides to the African superplume, Science, 296, 1850–1852, 2002.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ni, S., D. V. Helmberger, and J. Tromp, Three-dimensional structure of the African superplume from waveform modelling, Geophys. J. Int., 161, 283–294, 2005.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Panning, M. and B. Romanowicz, A three-dimensional radially anisotropic model of shear velocity in the whole mantle, Geophys. J. Int., 167, 361–379, 2006.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Resovsky, J. S. and M. H. Ritzwoller, Regularization uncertainty in density models estimated from normal mode data, Geophys. Res. Lett., 26, 2319–2322, 1999.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ritsema, J., S. Ni, and D. V. Helmberger, Evidence for strong shear velocity reductions and velocity gradients in the lower mantle beneath Africa, Geophys. Res. Lett., 25, 4245–4248, 1998.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ritsema, J., H. J. van Heijst, and H. Woodhouse, Complex shear wave velocity structure imaged beneath Africa and Iceland, Science, 286, 1925–1928, 1999.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ritzwoller, M. H., N. M. Shapiro, A. L. Levshin, and G. M. Leahy, Crustal and upper mantle structure beneath Antarctica and surrounding oceans, J. Geophys. Res., 106, 30645–30670, 2001.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Romanowicz, B., Can we resolve 3D density heterogeneity in the lower mantle?, Geophys. Res. Lett., 28, 1107–1110, 2001.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Romanowicz, B., Global mantle tomography: progress status in the past 10 years, Ann. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci., 31, 303–328, 2003.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Takeuchi, N., Whole mantle SH velocity model constrained by waveform inversion based on three-dimensional Born kernels, Geophys. J. Int., 169, 1153–1163, 2007.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Takeuchi, N., Y. Morita, N. D. Xuyen, and N. Q. Zung, Extent of the lowvelocity region in the lowermost mantle beneath the western Pacific detected by the Vietnamese Broadband Seismograph Array, Geophys. Res. Lett., 35, L05307, doi:10.1029/2008GL033197, 2008.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- To, A., B. Romanowicz, Y. Capdeville, and N. Takeuchi, 3D effects of sharp boundaries at the borders of the African and Pacific Superplumes: Observation and modeling, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 233, 137–153, 2005.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- van der Hilst, R. D., S. Widiyantro, and E. R. Engdahl, Evidence of deep mantle circulation from global tomography, Nature, 386, 578–584, 1997.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Volkova, L. V. and G. T. Zatsepin, Acad. Sci. U.S.S.R., Bull. Phys. Ser., 38, 151–154, 1974.Google Scholar
- Wang, Y. and L. X. Wen, Geometry and P and S velocity structure of the “African Anomaly”, J. Geophys. Res., 112, B05313, doi:10.1029/2006JB004483, 2007.Google Scholar
- Wilson, T. L., Neutrino tomography: Tevatron mapping versus the neutrino sky, Nature, 309, 38–42, 1984.View ArticleGoogle Scholar