A simulation study of the propagation of whistler-mode chorus in the Earth’s inner magnetosphere
© Katoh; licensee Springer. 2014
Received: 3 February 2014
Accepted: 11 March 2014
Published: 7 April 2014
We study the propagation of whistler-mode chorus in the magnetosphere by a spatially two-dimensional simulation code in the dipole coordinates. We set the simulation system so as to assume the outside of the plasmapause, corresponding to the radial distance from 3.9 to 4.1 RE in the equatorial plane and the latitudinal range from −15° to +15°, where RE is the Earth’s radius. We assume a model chorus element propagating northward from the magnetic equator of the field line at L=4 with a rising tone from 0.2 to 0.7 Ωe 0 in the time scale of 5,000
, where Ωe 0 is the electron gyrofrequency at the magnetic equator. For the initial density distribution of cold electrons, we assume three types of initial conditions in the outside of the plasmapause: without a duct (run 1), a density enhancement duct (run 2), and a density decrease duct (run 3). In run 1, the simulation result reveals that whistler-mode waves of the different wave frequencies propagate in the different ray path in the region away from the magnetic equator. In runs 2 and 3, the model chorus element propagates inside the assumed duct with changing wave normal angle. The simulation results show the different propagation properties of the chorus element in runs 2 and 3 and reveal that resultant wave spectra observed along the field line are different between the density enhancement and density decrease duct cases. The spectral modification of chorus by the propagation effect should play a significant role in the interactions between chorus and energetic electrons in the magnetosphere, particularly in the region away from the equator. The present study clarifies that the variation of propagation properties of chorus should be taken into account for the thorough understanding of resonant interactions of chorus with energetic electrons in the inner magnetosphere.
Whistler-mode chorus emissions are generated in the region close to the magnetic equator outside the plasmapause during geomagnetically disturbed periods. Spacecraft observations near the magnetic equator have revealed that chorus appear in the frequency range from 0.2 to 0.8 Ωe 0, where Ωe 0 is the electron gyrofrequency at the magnetic equator, while the frequency range of chorus is classified into the lower-band (0.2 to 0.5 Ωe 0) and upper-band chorus (0.5 to 0.8 Ωe 0) by a distinct gap at 0.5 Ωe 0 (Santolík et al. 2003). Observations have revealed that chorus typically propagate along a magnetic field line in its source region and become oblique during their propagation away from the equator. Propagation properties of chorus have been studied for a half of century (e.g., Smith et al. 1960; Bell et al. 2009). Theoretical estimations and results of ray tracing studies have been compared with observations of chorus in space and at high-latitude ground stations.
Chorus can resonate with electrons in a wide energy range from kiloelectron volts to megaelectron volts and play important roles in the energization process of radiation belt electrons (e.g., Katoh et al. 2008) and in the auroral electron precipitation process related to pulsating aurora (e.g., Nishiyama et al. 2011). Propagation properties of chorus are important in understanding resonant interactions with energetic electrons. While whistler-mode waves propagating parallel to the magnetic field direction are circularly polarized waves with purely electromagnetic components, interactions can be treated based on the cyclotron resonance condition. For a case of obliquely propagating whistler-mode waves, their wave electromagnetic fields exhibit longitudinal components, and the Landau resonance with energetic electrons becomes significant. The propagation properties of chorus are governed by the spatial distribution of ambient cold electrons controlling the dispersion relation of plasma waves. Previous studies have revealed conditions of trapping of whistler-mode waves within enhanced or depleted plasma density (Bell et al. 2009).
The generation process of chorus has been reproduced by self-consistent particle simulations (Katoh and Omura 2007;2011;2013). Since a spatially one-dimensional simulation system along a magnetic field line has been used in these simulations, whistler-mode waves of purely parallel propagation are treated. While essential processes of the chorus generation occurring in the region close to the magnetic equator can be well described by the assumption of the parallel propagation, observation results have revealed that generated chorus elements become oblique and propagate across field lines in the region away from the equator (e.g., Santolík et al. 2003). For the discussion of the propagation of chorus in the magnetosphere, we need to develop a spatially two-dimensional simulation code which enables us to treat whistler-mode waves propagating in arbitrary directions.
Ray tracing is a useful tool to understand propagation properties of chorus in the magnetosphere (Kimura 1966; Bortnik et al. 2008; Yamaguchi et al. 2013). Numerical experiments are also useful, even though an amount of computational resources are required in solving a set of Maxwell’s equations and the equation of motion of cold plasma, because they can reproduce the wave amplitude variation and the spatial extent of wave packets during their propagation (Streltsov et al. 200620102012). In the present study, we have developed a spatially two-dimensional simulation code for the study of the propagation of chorus in the dipole magnetic field. We show the validity of the developed simulation code and study variations of propagation properties of chorus by assuming the density enhancement and decrease in the magnetosphere. Simulation results also reveal that spectra of rising tone chorus are significantly modified during the propagation of chorus in the region away from the equator. The present study clarifies that the variation of propagation properties of chorus should be taken into account for the thorough understanding of resonant interactions of chorus with energetic electrons in the inner magnetosphere. We describe the simulation model in the ‘Methods’ section. In the ‘Results and discussion’ section, we present simulation results and discuss the propagation properties of chorus in the simulation results. The ‘Conclusions’ section gives a summary of the present study.
where the h axis is along a magnetic field line, the ν axis is perpendicular to the h axis and is defined in the meridional plane, the ϕ axis completes the right-hand system, and a is a constant related to the grid distribution along a field line.
where N0 is the number density at the magnetic equator of the magnetic field line of L=4, r0 represents the location of the inner edge of the simulation system at the magnetic equator and is 3.9 RE from the center of the Earth, Δ rpp is the spatial scale of the density gradient at the plasmapause and is assumed to be 0.033 RE, and Neq,min is the minimum of the equatorial number density. In Figure 2b, we assume Neq,min=N0. The spatial distribution of the number density in the region away from the equator is determined by referring Neq(req) and the diffusive equilibrium along a magnetic field line (Angerami and Thomas 1964). We obtain the ratio between the plasma frequency and the electron gyrofrequency, ω p /Ω e , by the dipole magnetic field and the assumed spatial distribution of cold electrons, as shown in Figure 2c. We assume N0 so that ω p /Ω e becomes 4.0 at the magnetic equator of L=4.
Results and discussion
Using the simulation model described in the previous section, we study the propagation of whistler-mode waves with a rising tone in the inner magnetosphere. We inject northward propagating whistler-mode waves from the magnetic equator of the field line at L=4 with varying its frequency in time, as a model chorus element. The wave frequency is varied from 0.2 to 0.7 Ωe 0 with the time scale of 5,000 . The assumed frequency range covers the entire frequency range of typical lower-band and upper-band chorus emissions, and the time scale and the frequency sweep rate of the rising tone correspond to 58 ms and 117 kHz/s, respectively, for the magnetic field intensity of 486 nT at the equator of L=4. The assumed time scale is comparable to those of typical chorus emissions (Santolík et al. 2003), while the assumed sweep rate is a few times higher than typical sweep rates. The wave amplitude of the model chorus element is assumed to be 10−4B0, where B0 is the intensity of the background magnetic field at the magnetic equator of L=4. We study propagation properties of the model chorus element under three types of background plasma conditions: outside of the plasmapause (run 1), a density enhancement (run 2), and a density decrease(run 3).
Run 1: propagation of a rising tone chorus element outside the plasmapause
Runs 2 and 3: duct propagation of a rising tone chorus element
Figure 7e,f,g,h shows the time evolution of the wave magnetic field amplitude in the simulation system for the case of the density decrease (run 3). We find that the model chorus element propagated along the field line of L=4, similar to the results shown in Figure 7a,b,c,d, while the wave amplitude slightly enhanced at the leading edge in the case of the density decrease. Figure 8e,f,g,h shows the wave normal angle of the waves. As we found in the case of the density enhancement, the wave normal angle of the element varied within the limited range during its propagation away from the equator.
The propagation properties of whistler-mode waves in the magnetosphere under the presence of the density gradient have also been studied in Woodroffe and Streltsov (2013a,b). The properties of the wave propagation shown in the present simulation results are consistent with those reported in the previous works. By employing a large simulation system compared with those used in the previous studies (the system is four times and ten times larger in the Z and X directions, respectively, than that used in Woodroffe and Streltsov (2013b)), we have demonstrated in the present study how the wave spectra are modified by the propagation effect.
Santolík et al. (2003) showed Cluster observation that chorus propagate nearly parallel to the field lines in the region close to the magnetic equator and the average wave vector directions gradually become inclined at higher latitudes (approximately 10°). The present simulation results shown in Figure 4 are consistent with the observation results. Li et al. (2011) studied the relationship between the amplitude of chorus and the density variations observed by THEMIS spacecraft. They showed that both density enhancement and density decrease are correlated with increases of wave amplitude, depending on the local time of the observation. While they proposed the modulation of the linear growth rate as a potential mechanism, the suggested relationship between the wave amplitude and the density distribution might be explained by the propagation effect as discussed in the present study. We expect fruitful discussions by comparing observation of chorus with results of the presentsimulation.
We expect that the spectral modification by the propagation effect revealed by the present study plays a significant role in the resonant scattering process between chorus and energetic electrons in the magnetosphere. While energetic electrons are bouncing along a field line and resonate with a chorus element, for the case of the duct propagation, the time scale of the interaction is controlled by the spatial scale of ducts. If the spatial scale of ducts is comparable to the gyroradius of energetic electrons, since the deviation of the wave packet from the field line is small during the propagation, electrons can resonate with the entire wave element of chorus. On the other hand, if the spatial scale of ducts is larger than the gyroradius, the wave element often deviates from the field line and the electrons only interact with a part of the wave element, resulting in the limited time scale of resonant interactions. The present study clarified that the variation of propagation properties of chorus should be taken into account for the thorough understanding of resonant interactions of chorus with energetic electrons in the inner magnetosphere. The same discussion can also be applied to the acceleration of relativistic electrons in the outer radiation belt, since the concentration of wave amplitude within the duct should affect the time scale of wave-particle interactions between chorus and relativistic electrons. It is interesting to evaluate the efficiency of the acceleration by computing the motion of relativistic electrons simultaneously with the presentsimulation.
We developed a spatially two-dimensional simulation code in the dipole coordinates (h, ν) for the study of the propagation of whistler-mode chorus in the magnetosphere. We set the simulation system so as to simulate the outside of the plasmapause, corresponding to the radial distance from 3.9 to 4.1 RE in the equatorial plane and the latitudinal range from −15° to +15°. We assumed a model chorus element propagating northward from the magnetic equator of the field line of L=4 with a rising tone from 0.2 to 0.7 Ωe 0 in the time scale of 5,000 . For the density distribution of cold electrons, we assumed three types of initial conditions in the outside of the plasmapause: without a duct (run 1), a density enhancement duct (run 2), and a density decrease duct (run 3). In run 1, the simulation result revealed that whistler-mode waves of different wave frequencies propagated in the different ray path in the region away from the magnetic equator. In runs 2 and 3, we found that the model chorus element propagated inside the assumed duct with changing wave normal angle. The simulation results showed the different propagation properties of the chorus element in runs 2 and 3 and revealed that resultant wave spectra observed along the field line were different between the density enhancement and density decrease duct cases.
The spectral modification of chorus by the propagation effect should play a significant role in the interactions between chorus and energetic electrons in the magnetosphere, particularly in the region away from the equator. For the quantitative evaluation of the effect of the propagation properties on the resonant scattering process, the motion of energetic electrons should be computed simultaneously with the present simulation. We leave them for the future study.
The author thanks N. Terada for the discussion on the implementation of the dipole coordinates in the simulation code. The computation was performed with computer facilities at Research Institute for Sustainable Humanosphere and Academic Center for Computing and Media Studies of Kyoto University, Solar-Terrestrial Environment Laboratory of Nagoya University, and Research Institute for Information Technology of Kyushu University. This work was supported by Grant for Young Scientist of Graduate School of Science, Tohoku University.
- Angerami JJ, Thomas JO: Studies of planetary atmospheres: 1. The distribution of ions and electrons in the Earth’s exosphere. J Geophys Res 1964, 69: 4537–4560. doi:10.1029/JZ069i021p04537View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bell TF, Inan US, Haque N, Pickett JS: Source regions of banded chorus. Geophys Res Lett 2009, 36: L11101. doi:10.1029/2009GL037629View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bortnik J, Thorne RM, Meredith NP: The unexpected origin of plasmaspheric hiss from discrete chorus emissions. Nature 2008, 452: 62–66. doi:10.1038/nature06741View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Haque N, Inan US, Bell TF, Pickett JS, Trotignon JG, Facskó G: Cluster observations of whistler mode ducts and banded chorus. Geophys Res Lett 2011, 38: L18107. doi:10.1029/2011GL049112View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Katoh Y, Omura Y: A study of generation mechanism of VLF triggered emission by self-consistent particle code. J Geophys Res 2006, 111: A12207. doi:10.1029/2006JA011704View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Omura Y, Katoh, Y: Computer simulation of chorus wave generation in the Earth’s inner magnetosphere. Geophys Res Lett 2007, 34: L03102. doi:10.1029/2006GL028594Google Scholar
- Katoh Y, Omura Y, Summers D: Rapid energization of radiation belt electrons by nonlinear wave trapping. Ann Geophys 2008, 26: 3451–3456. 10.5194/angeo-26-3451-2008View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Katoh Y, Omura Y: Amplitude dependence of frequency sweep rates of whistler mode chorus emissions. J Geophys Res 2011, 116: A07201. doi:10.1029/2011JA016496Google Scholar
- Omura Y, Katoh, Y: Effect of the background magnetic field inhomogeneity on generation processes of whistler-mode chorus and broadband hiss-like emissions. J Geophys Res Space Phys 2013, 118: 4189–4198. doi:10.1002/jgra.50395View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kageyama A, Sugiyama T, Watanabe K, Sato T: A note on the dipole coordinates. Comput Geosci 2006, 32: 265–269. doi:10.1016/j.cageo.2005.06.006View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kimura I: Effects of ions on whistler-mode ray tracing. Radio Sci 1966, 1: 269–283.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Li W, Bortnik J, Thorne RM, Nishimura Y, Angelopoulos V, Chen L: Modulation of whistler mode chorus waves: 2. Role of density variations. J Geophys Res 2011, 116: A06206. doi:10.1029/2010JA016313Google Scholar
- Nishiyama T, Sakanoi T, Miyoshi Y, Katoh Y, Asamura K, Okano S, Hirahara M: The source region and its characteristic of pulsating aurora based on the Reimei observations. J Geophys Res 2011, 116: A03226. doi:10.1029/2010JA015507Google Scholar
- Santolík O, Gurnett DA, Pickett JS: Spatio-temporal structure of storm-time chorus. J Geophys Res 2003, 108: 1278. doi:10.1029/2002JA009791View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Smith RL, Helliwell RA, Yabroff IW: A theory of trapping of whistlers in field-aligned columns of enhanced ionization. J Geophys Res 1960, 65: 815–823. doi:10.1029/JZ065i003p00815View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Streltsov AV, Lampe M, Manheimer W, Ganguli G, Joyce G: Whistler propagation in inhomogeneous plasma. J Geophys Res 2006, 111: A03216. doi:10.1029/2005JA011357Google Scholar
- Streltsov AV, Golkowski M, Inan US, Papadopoulos KD: Propagation of whistler-mode waves with a modulated frequency in the magnetosphere. J Geophys Res 2010, 115: A09209. doi:10.1029/2009JA015155Google Scholar
- Streltsov AV, Woodroffe JR, Huba JD: Propagation of whistler mode waves through the ionosphere. J Geophys Res 2012, 117: A08302. doi:10.1029/2012JA017886Google Scholar
- Umeda T, Omura Y, Matsumoto H: An improved masking method for absorbing boundaries in electromagnetic particle simulations. Comput Phys Commun 2001, 137: 286–299. 10.1016/S0010-4655(01)00182-5View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Woodroffe JR, Streltsov AV: Whistler interactions with density gradients in the magnetosphere. J Geophys Res 2013a, 118: 1–6. doi:10.1029/2012JA018308Google Scholar
- Streltsov AV, Woodroffe, JR: Whistler propagation in the plasmapause. J Geophys Res Space Phys 2013b, 118: 716–723. doi:10.1002/jgra.50135View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yamaguchi K, Matsumuro T, Omura Y, Nunn D: Ray tracing of whistler-mode chorus elements: implications for generation mechanisms of rising and falling tone emissions. Ann Geophys 2013, 31: 665–673. 10.5194/angeo-31–665–2013View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yoon PH: Large-amplitude whistler waves and electron acceleration. Geophys Res Lett 2011, 38: L12105. doi:10.1029/2011GL047893View ArticleGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited.