Skip to main content

Magnetostratigraphic evidence for post-depositional distortion of osmium isotopic records in pelagic clay and its implications for mineral flux estimates

Abstract

Chemical stratigraphy is useful for dating deep-sea sediments, which sometimes lack radiometric or biostratigraphic constraints. Oxic pelagic clay contains Fe–Mn oxyhydroxides that can retain seawater 187Os/188Os values, and its age can be estimated by fitting the isotopic ratios to the seawater 187Os/188Os curve. On the other hand, the stability of Fe–Mn oxyhydroxides is sensitive to redox change, and it is not clear whether the original 187Os/188Os values are always preserved in sediments. However, due to the lack of independent age constraints, the reliability of 187Os/188Os ages of pelagic clay has never been tested. Here we report inconsistency between magnetostratigraphic and 187Os/188Os ages in pelagic clay around Minamitorishima Island. In a ~ 5-m-thick interval, previous studies correlated 187Os/188Os data to a brief (< 1 million years) isotopic excursion in the late Eocene. Paleomagnetic measurements revealed at least 12 polarity zones in the interval, indicating a > 2.9–6.9 million years duration. Quartz and feldspars content showed that while the paleomagnetic chronology gives reasonable eolian flux estimates, the 187Os/188Os chronology leads to unrealistically high values. These results suggest that the low 187Os/188Os signal has diffused from an original thin layer to the current ~ 5-m interval, causing an underestimate of the deposition duration. The preservation of the polarity patterns indicates that a mechanical mixing such as bioturbation cannot be the main process for the diffusion, so diagenetic redistribution of Fe–Mn oxyhydroxides and associated Os may be responsible. The paleomagnetic chronology presented here also demands reconsiderations of the timing, accumulation rate, and origins of the high content of rare-earth elements and yttrium in pelagic clay around Minamitorishima Island.

Introduction

Hydrogenous Os isotopic ratios are useful chronological markers for unfossiliferous pelagic clay, especially around the Eocene–Oligocene boundary (e.g., Peucker-Ehrenbrink and Ravizza 2012). Oxic pelagic clay contains Fe–Mn oxyhydroxides precipitated from seawater (e.g., Uramoto et al. 2019). These oxyhydroxides capture osmium in seawater (Koide et al. 1991) and record the 187Os/188Os at the time of deposition. In the late Eocene, seawater 187Os/188Os show a large excursion to unradiogenic (low 187Os/188Os) values (Ravizza and Peucker-Ehrenbrink 2003). This excursion was identified not only in pelagic clay (Pegram and Turekian 1999) and ferromanganese crusts (Klemm et al. 2005; Nielsen et al. 2009), but also in biogenic sediments with high-resolution biostratigraphic and magnetostratigraphic age models (Ravizza and Peucker-Ehrenbrink 2003; Dalai et al. 2006). The age of the 187Os/188Os minimum was estimated to be 34.5 ± 0.1 Ma (Dalai et al. 2006). It has also been proposed that dating of pelagic clay with ~ 0.1 million-year (Myr) resolution is possible by matching the shape of the excursion (Dalai et al. 2006; Nozaki et al. 2019; Ohta et al. 2020). However, the reliability of this method critically depends on the assumptions that Fe–Mn oxyhydroxides are hydrogenous and have been stable since deposition (e.g., Peucker-Ehrenbrink and Ravizza 2000).

Processes such as bioturbation and diagenesis can diffuse Fe–Mn oxyhydroxides either mechanically or chemically, so they can potentially distort the Os isotopic records. Bioturbation appears to be ubiquitous, even in pelagic clay of oligotrophic oceans (e.g., Rutledge et al. 1995; Expedition 329 Scientists 2011). Detailed geochemical studies of sediments and Fe–Mn nodules in the northeastern Pacific suggested that deep-sea redox conditions may have varied in response to surface productivity changes even if it is oxic at present (Mewes et al. 2014; Wegorzewski and Kuhn 2014). Diagenetic Fe–Mn micronodules were reported from surface clay in the western Pacific (Li et al. 2020). Abundant magnetite produced by magnetotactic bacteria was also found in oxic pelagic clay (Yamazaki and Shimono 2013; Shimono and Yamazaki 2016; Usui et al. 2017, 2019). These bacteria are thought to live near oxic/anoxic transition, suggesting the presence of reducing microenvironment (Yamazaki and Shimono 2013).

Because pelagic clay generally has a low sedimentation rate (< 1 m/Myr), post-depositional modifications would affect the reliability of 187Os/188Os stratigraphy. To date, however, no pelagic clay with 187Os/188Os data has been accompanied by independent age constraints with sufficient resolution to confirm the stability of the isotopic records. In this study, we report the magnetostratigraphy within the putative late Eocene 187Os/188Os excursion in pelagic clay around Minamitorishima Island. Flux estimates for eolian dust and fish debris are discussed to evaluate the different chronologies.

Materials

We studied pelagic clay recovered by a piston core MR14-E02 PC11 around Minamitorishima Island at 154°00.98′E, 22°59.02′N, and 5,647 m water depth (Additional file 1). The core length was 13.12 m. The sediments were brown to dark brown clay. There was a manganese-rich layer at 4.12–4.33 m core depth. Lithological observation suggests it represents a hiatus. A 187Os/188Os excursion in this core was interpreted as the late Eocene excursion (Nozaki et al. 2019), as well as in a nearby core KR13-02 PC05 (Ohta et al. 2020). Geochemical and magnetic correlations confirmed that they are in the same stratigraphic position (Tanaka et al. 2020; Yamazaki et al. 2020).

In both cores, the 187Os/188Os excursions roughly coincide with the high concentrations (> 2000 ppm) of rare-earth elements and yttrium (REY), labeled as the 1st REY peak (Iijima et al. 2016; Tanaka et al. 2020). REY in pelagic clay are mainly carried by fish debris consisting of biogenic apatite (Kashiwabara et al. 2014, 2018; Yasukawa et al. 2016), especially in this region (Takaya et al. 2018; Yasukawa et al. 2019). From these observations, Ohta et al. (2020) proposed that fish production increased significantly at ~ 34.4 Ma in response to the expansion of the Antarctic ice sheet (Katz et al. 2008).

Methods

Paleomagnetism and rock magnetism

Cubic samples were taken from the archive halves of the core by pushing 7-cm3 plastic cubes. The samples were taken continuously, and every other cube was used for this study, resulting in a resolution of ~ 4.5 cm. The interval 1.2–1.7 m was disturbed by coring, and the interval 3.9–4.9 m was very stiff due to Mn enrichment. Consequently, we did not sample these intervals. A hiatus was estimated at ~ 4.2 m based on lithological changes (Nozaki et al. 2019). Progressive AF demagnetizations of natural remanence were conducted using a cryogenic magnetometer 2G Enterprises 760 at the Center for Advanced Marine Core Research (CMCR), Kochi University. The results were analyzed by principal component analysis to isolate characteristic remanence (Kirschvink 1980). We use results with maximum angular deviation (MAD) smaller than 15° for further analyses. Because the core was not azimuthally oriented, we first estimated polarity patterns by near 180° changes in relative declination and inclination sign. For intervals with possible polarity changes, we calculated virtual geomagnetic pole (VGP). We used the VGP latitude, which combines information from declination and inclination, for further interpretation. Chronostratigraphy was estimated by comparing the polarity patterns with the geomagnetic polarity time scale (GPTS) in Geological Time Scale 2012 (Ogg 2012).

Magnetic properties of the samples were examined to help paleomagnetic interpretation. We measured the ratio of anhysteretic remanence (ARM) susceptibility (κARM) to saturation isothermal remanence (SIRM) and S ratios (Bloemendal et al. 1992). In the Minamitorishima region, κARM/SIRM reflects the abundance of biogenic magnetite relative to terrigenous magnetic minerals (Usui et al. 2017, 2019; Yamazaki et al. 2020). After paleomagnetic measurements, ARMs were imparted with a 0.1 mT DC field and 80 mT peak AF field using the cryogenic magnetometer at CMCR. IRMs were imparted with 2.5 T field using a pulse magnetizer magnetic measurements model MMPM-10 at Atmosphere and Ocean Research Institute, the University of Tokyo. S ratios measure the relative abundance of minerals with contrasting coercivity. SIRM measurements were followed by IRMs imparted by back fields of − 0.1 and − 0.3 T. S ratios (S−0.1 and S−0.3) were calculated following the definition of Bloemendal et al. (1992). In pelagic sediments, S-0.1 and S-0.3 often reflect the relative abundance of biogenic magnetite to abiotic (eolian) magnetic minerals, and ferromagnetic minerals to antiferromagnetic minerals (e.g., hematite), respectively (e.g., Bloemendal et al. 1992; Yamazaki 2009; Usui et al. 2017).

Quartz and feldspar content

To quantify eolian dust content, we separated quartz and feldspars using the sodium pyrosulfate (Na2S2O7) fusion method (Kiely and Jackson 1964; Syers et al. 1968; Clayton et al. 1972; Blatt et al. 1982; Stevens 1991; Usui et al. 2018). Dry samples of ~ 1 g were first treated with citrate–bicarbonate–dithionite (CBD) to remove poorly crystalline Fe–Mn oxyhydroxides (Rea and Janecek 1981). The residues were washed with purified water, freeze-dried, weighed, and treated with acetic acid overnight, which has been assumed to remove carbonate and apatite. The oxyhydroxides-free residues were washed, freeze-dried, weighed, and fused with Na2S2O7 at 460 °C, which decompose sheet silicates. The fusions were treated with 3 N HCl and washed with purified water to remove solidified potassium pyrosulfate and relict clays. Then, the residues were heated to 50 °C in 1 M NaOH overnight to remove relict clays.

Results

Rock magnetism

Rock magnetic properties showed smooth variations (Fig. 1). κARM/SIRM were ~ 1 mm/A down to ~ 6 m. They increased to > 2.0 mm/A below ~ 7 m into the 1st REY peak, indicating dominance of biogenic magnetite over terrigenous magnetic minerals. These behaviors are consistent with those of nearby cores (Usui et al. 2017; Yamazaki et al. 2020). S ratios were high, indicating limited contribution from antiferromagnetic minerals. S−0.1 were close to 1 between ~ 6 and 12 m (Fig. 1b), indicating dominance of low-coercivity minerals such as biogenic magnetite. S−0.3 were slightly lower below ~ 12 m (chemostratigraphic Unit III of Tanaka et al. 2020), suggesting an increase in antiferromagnetic minerals such as hematite.

Fig. 1
figure 1

Depth variations of rock magnetic and paleomagnetic results. a κARM/SIRM. b S ratios. Open circles represent S−0.1, and crosses represent S-0.3. c Relative declination. The core was not azimuthally oriented with respect to the geographic coordinates. d Inclination. Vertical lines show expected inclinations for geocentric axial dipole. Gray dashed lines are for 24º latitude (present day), and red dotted lines are for 16º latitude (~ 35 Ma; Matthews et al., 2016). e Maximum angular deviation (MAD). Gray symbols show data with MAD > 15°, which are not plotted in c and d. f Variation of total REY content (Iijima et al., 2016). On the right are chemostratigraphic Units of Tanaka et al. (2020)

Paleomagnetism

Clear polarity patterns were obtained at limited intervals (Fig. 1c, d). Top ~ 8 m was characterized by stable declination dominated by apparent normal polarity (positive inclination; Fig. 1d). Considering the proposed chronology (~ 2 Ma at 0.01 m and ~ 34 Ma at ~ 7 m; Nozaki et al. 2019), we interpreted that this normal polarity is not an original signal but reflect viscous overprint and cancellation of a dual polarity due to slow sedimentation. This interpretation is partly supported by the presence of normal polarity overprints in samples with characteristic remanence with negative inclinations (Additional file 2b). Consequently, we did not assign polarity above 8 m. Below 8 m, changes in inclination signs together with near 180° changes in relative declination were observed (Fig. 1c, d). The absolute inclination is slightly larger in samples with positive inclinations. We interpreted this is also due to incomplete removal of the viscous overprint.

We calculated the VGP positions for intervals below 8 m. To calculate the VGP, we corrected the core orientation assuming that the mean of the relative declinations of the samples with negative inclinations correspond to geographic south. The VGP latitude showed swings between + 50º and − 60º (Fig. 2). The plate motion after sedimentation and the incomplete removal of viscous overprint would reduce the quality of the VGP data. We simply assign normal and reversed polarities to the intervals with positive and negative VGP latitudes, respectively (Fig. 2; Additional file 3). Above ~ 8.5 m, the VGP latitude showed small oscillation around 0º. This is unlikely to be the geomagnetic signal; rather, it mainly reflects the anomalous declination (Fig. 1c). We did not interpret the polarity in this interval. The core showed 12 polarity zones with comparable lengths between 8.5 and 13 m.

Fig. 2
figure 2

a Depth variation of VGP latitude. b Interpreted polarity. Black represents normal polarity, white represents reversed polarity, and gray represents an interval of uncertain polarity (see text for discussion)

Quartz and feldspars content

The CBD treatment reduced the sample weight by 10–20% (Fig. 3a). This can be considered as approximated weight fractions of Fe–Mn oxyhydroxides. The weight change was ~ 10% at the top, gradually increased with depth to ~ 15–20% towards ~ 6 m.

Fig. 3
figure 3

Chemical digestion results. a Weight fraction of residue after CBD treatment (open circles) and subsequent acetic acid treatment (crosses). b Weight fraction of residue after sodium pyrosulfate fusion

Acetic acid treatment further reduced the weight; the change was largest in ~ 7–12 m where REY concentrations were high. This is consistent with the interpretation that fish debris carries REY (Iijima et al. 2016; Ohta et al. 2020). However, the change was at most ~ 5% of the original weight. On the other hand, there is a strong linear relationship between P2O5 and REY content in sediments around Minamitorishima Island (Iijima et al. 2016; Takaya et al. 2018), suggesting the fraction of fish debris is nearly proportional to REY content. Using data from KR13-02 PC05 (Ohta et al. 2020), we can estimate that MR14-E02 PC11 clay (REY content up to 4000 ppm) contains up to ~ 20 wt.% of fish debris. It is thus likely that acetic acid treatment does not remove biogenic apatite effectively.

Na2S2O7 fusion further reduced the sample weight to ~ 15–30 wt.% of the original weight (Fig. 3b). We consider these weights as the quartz and feldspars content. The highest content was from the top of the core. Below 7 m, it was ~ 15 wt.%. Note that these numbers are affected by Fe–Mn oxyhydroxides and fish debris content; given ~ 15 wt.% of Fe–Mn oxyhydroxides and up to ~ 20 wt.% of fish debris below 7 m, the weight fraction of quartz and feldspar relative to total silicate may be ~ 20 below 7 m and ~ 20–30 wt.% throughout the core.

Discussion

Chronostratigraphy and eolian flux estimates

Our paleomagnetic data show that there are at least 12 polarity zones in 8.5–13 m (Fig. 2). Rock magnetic properties change smoothly in this interval (Fig. 1a, b), so these polarity zones are likely to reflect the geomagnetic reversals rather than short-scale variations in overprint. 187Os/188Os were as low as 0.3 in 7–12 m, and previous interpretations correlated them to the late Eocene excursion (Nozaki et al. 2019). However, this interpretation would put the 7–12 m interval into a single chron of C13r (Fig. 4), while individual reversed polarity zones are < 50 cm in the core (Fig. 2).

Fig. 4
figure 4

Age–depth plot based on 187Os/188Os (blue circles; Nozaki et al. 2019) and paleomagnetism (gray crosses; Additional file 3: Table 1). Also shown is the 187Os/188Os ages of KR13-02 PC05 (orange triangles; Ohta et al. 2020). Shown at the bottom is the geomagnetic polarity time scale (Ogg 2012). Black represents normal polarity, white represents reversed polarity

Because there are only ichthyoliths stratigraphy constraints for late Eocene–early Oligocene ages of the corresponding 1st REY peak in KR13-02 PC05 (Ohta et al. 2020), we cannot correlate the observed polarity zones with GPTS uniquely. Nonetheless, based on the ichthyoliths data and the low 187Os/188Os, we infer that the late Eocene 187Os/188Os excursion (~ 34.5 Ma) is somewhere in the 7–12 m interval. With this inference, we can list possible correlations with GPTS (Additional File 3; Fig. 4). Here we assumed that the sedimentation was continuous, and all the major chrons are recorded. These assumptions lead to conservative estimates for the depositional duration. The deepest polarity transition (11.96 m), which coincides with the beginning of the 1st REY peak, would be between 34.999 and 38.615 Ma, and the shallowest polarity transition (9.01 m), which is deeper than the end of the 1st REY peak (7 m), would be between 28.141 and 35.706 Ma. All of these magnetostratigraphic correlations indicate that the deposition of the 1st REY peak took much longer (> 2.9–6.9 Myr) than the 187Os/188Os ages (< 1 Myr; Nozaki et al. 2019; Ohta et al. 2020). The linear sedimentation rate between 9.01 and 11.96 m is estimated to be 0.43–1.02 m/Myr, depending on the correlation to GPTS (Additional File 3). They are much smaller than the sedimentation rate estimate for the 1st REY peak based on 187Os/188Os (Nozaki et al. 2019; Ohta et al. 2020), but similar to the sedimentation rate above the 1st REY peak (Fig. 4).

Inconsistency between the magnetostratigraphy and 187Os/188Os ages can be compared in terms of the eolian flux. The chemical digestion results (Fig. 3) show that quartz and feldspars account for ~ 10–20 wt.% of the dry sediments of the 1st REY peak. 187Os/188Os suggest the sedimentation rate of ~ 3.3 m/Myr for the 1st REY peak of MR14-E02 PC11 (Nozaki et al. 2019; Fig. 4). Using a typical dry bulk density of 500 kg/m3 (Ohta et al. 2020), these numbers are converted to a quartz and feldspars flux of ~ 165–330 kg/m2/Myr. Typically, quartz and feldspars account for 10–20 wt.% of eolian dust (Blank et al. 1985; Leinen et al. 1994; Usui et al. 2018), which is broadly consistent with our estimate of ~ 20–30 wt.% of the silicate. These numbers indicate > 500 kg/m2/Myr of eolian flux. This is comparable to the current flux to the Pacific at ~ 16ºN (Rea 1994), where Minamitorishima Island was at ~ 35 Ma. However, multiple records from the North Pacific indicated that the eolian flux has increased by more than tenfold since 25 Ma (e.g., Zhang et al. 2016). Only a few estimates exist for flux before 30 Ma, but it may be even smaller between 35 and 45 Ma (Janecek and Rea 1983; Janecek 1985). Thus, the flux estimates based on the 187Os/188Os seem too large. In contrast, the magnetostratigraphy suggests sedimentation rates of 0.43–1.02 m/Myr in the 1st REY peak (Fig. 4). They are converted to eolian flux estimates of ~ 70–500 kg/m2/Myr. The lower end of the range is consistent with the evolution of the eolian flux in the North Pacific. Therefore, we argue that the 187Os/188Os ages overestimate the sedimentation rate of the 1st REY peak. We further consider that GPTS correlations which give slower sedimentation rates (< 0.5 m/Myr) are more plausible, implying that the deposition of the 1st REY took more than 6.5 Myr and completed later than 30 Ma (Fig. 4).

Possible mechanisms for the distortion of the osmium isotope record

187Os/188Os are stably low throughout the 1st REY peak, while the magnetostratigraphy predicts < 50 cm excursion (Fig. 5). Although processes such as extraterrestrial influx can modify the absolute 187Os/188Os values, it is unlikely to eliminate only the excursion. Rather, the simplest explanation for the absence of a short excursion is post-depositional homogenization of 187Os/188Os. Complete mechanical mixing by processes such as bioturbation over ~ 5 m interval is unlikely, and they would also destroy the polarity records. So, we suspect chemical remobilization of Fe–Mn oxyhydroxides as a cause of the homogeneous 187Os/188Os. The 1st REY peak represents enhanced flux of fish debris, which may have brought oxic–anoxic transition zone to shallow depths, promoting diagenetic movement of Mn (Mewes et al. 2014; Wegorzewski and Kuhn 2014).

Fig. 5
figure 5

Comparisons of magnetostratigraphy and 187Os/188Os records. a Depth variation of 187Os/188Os (Nozaki et al. 2019) together with inferred polarity zones of MR14-E02 PC11 for 5–12 m (Fig. 1). The inset is the 187Os/188Os for the entire core. A negative excursion at ~ 3.5 m was interpreted as a Miocene impact event (Nozaki et al. 2019). b Seawater 187Os/188Os data for 28–41 Ma together with the geomagnetic polarity time scale (Ogg 2012). The 187Os/188Os data are from ferromanganese crust (gray diamonds; Nielsen et al. 2009), pelagic clay (yellow open inverted triangles; Pegram and Turekian 1999), radiolarite and nannofossil ooze (filled circles; Dalai et al. 2006), and nannofossil and radiolarian ooze (open blue triangles; Paquay et al. 2008). The chronology of ferromanganese crust was based on the 187Os/188Os correlation to ~ 11–12 Ma, ~ 34.4 Ma, and ~ 55.5 Ma and linear interpolation between them with some adjustments. The chronology of pelagic clay is based on constant a Co flux model which may have 5–10 Myr offset in this interval (Kyte et al. 1993)

A simple averaging of the seawater 187Os/188Os curve does not reproduce the absolute values observed in the core (Fig. 5b), suggesting additional processes were at work. We note three factors that help to resolve this problem, although these are not exhaustive and further quantitative research is required. First, Os influx to sediments may be variable, so homogenization involves taking weighted averages of the seawater curve. If the original Os deposition was sufficiently larger during the isotopic excursion than other period, then the 187Os/188Os after homogenization would be low, and Os content would be high. This is qualitatively consistent with the elevated Os content in the 1st REY peak of KR13-02 PC05 (Ohta et al. 2020); however, the Os content of MR14-E02 PC11 does not show a similar pattern (Nozaki et al. 2019), so the contribution of this factor may be limited. Second, 187Os/188Os may not be globally uniform. The 187Os/188Os minima in the excursion differ by ~ 0.05 in two high-resolution sites from the eastern equatorial Pacific (e.g., Peucker-Ehrenbrink and Ravizza 2012). This amount alone may be insufficient to explain the low 187Os/188Os in the 1st REY peak, but such heterogeneity should be considered. Finally, the 187Os/188Os of pelagic sediments may be contaminated by unradiogenic extraterrestrial and ultramafic components to yield lower values (e.g., Peucker-Ehrenbrink and Ravizza 2000). The 187Os/188Os in the Minamitorishima samples were analyzed using the Carius tube methods with reverse aqua regia (Shirey and Walker 1995), which would introduce extraterrestrial and ultramafic components, although the absolute abundance of these components are not known. Some argued that more diluted leaching solution (0.15% H2O2) should be used to minimize the effect of extraterrestrial components (Turekian and Pegram 1997). Indeed, Nozaki et al. (2019) reported low 187Os/188Os due to an influx of extraterrestrial material from a Miocene impact event in the same core studied here. These factors may affect the 187Os/188Os dating outside the 1st REY peak as well.

Implication for the fish debris accumulation estimates

The proposed revision of the chronology for the 1st REY peak affects the estimates of fish debris accumulation rates and the origin of the REY peaks. On the basis of the 187Os/188Os ages, Ohta et al. (2020) estimated high fish debris accumulation rates of > 300 kg/m2/Myr for the 1st REY peak in KR13-02 PC05. Our paleomagnetic data indicate that the deposition of the 1st REY peak may have taken > 10 times longer. Therefore, we suggest that the maximum fish debris accumulation rate in the 1st REY peak was on the order of 10 kg/m2/Myr. Indeed, assuming a fish debris content of 20 wt.%, the paleomagnetic linear sedimentation rates indicate that the peak fish debris accumulation rate for MR14-E02 PC11 was 43–101 kg/m2/Myr. The fact that the REY content shows a sharp maximum even within the 1st REY peak indicates significant temporal variation of the fish debris accumulation. Cenozoic fish debris accumulation rate in the central North Pacific can also be estimated using data from the core LL44-GPC3 (Kyte et al. 1993). Assuming that P2O5 is exclusively in fish debris at ~ 30 wt.% (Kon et al. 2014; Takaya et al. 2018), the estimated rate was mostly below 10 kg/m2/Myr except for a peak at ~ 66 Ma and another smaller peak at ~ 58 Ma (see Additional file 4). Thus, the formation of the 1st REY peak around Minamitorishima Island still requires an explanation.

Ohta et al. (2020) suggested that the enhanced fish debris accumulation is related to the bottom water upwelling during the brief ice volume expansion at ~ 34.15 Ma (Katz et al. 2008). While upwelling is still a viable hypothesis, the paleomagnetic chronology indicates that the 1st REY peak reflects longer-term changes. The present paleomagnetic chronology cannot place unique ages (Additional file 3); a better chronology is needed to test the connections to specific paleoenvironmental events for the beginning and end of the 1st REY peak.

Conclusion

Magnetostratigraphy of MR14-E02 PC11 indicates > 2.9–6.9 Myr duration for the deposition of a layer where 187Os/188Os was previously correlated to a < 1 Myr excursion. Eolian flux estimates based on the direct measurements of quartz and feldspar content support that a duration longer than 6 Myr is plausible. The inconsistency may have resulted from diagenetic redistribution of Fe–Mn oxyhydroxides and associated Os under high biogenic flux. The revised chronology indicates that the fish debris accumulation rate in the interval was an order of magnitude lower than the previous estimates; nonetheless, it may be still significantly higher than other areas or time. The elevated fish debris flux is likely to be associated with long-term oceanographic changes rather than a single event. Our results indicate that high-resolution dating of pelagic clay using 187Os/188Os should be conducted with care.

Availability of data and materials

All data produced in this work are available in Zenodo repository (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4023918).

Abbreviations

Myr:

Million-year

REY:

Rare-earth elements and yttrium

ARM:

Anhysteretic remanence

SIRM:

Saturation isothermal remanence

IRM:

Isothermal remanence

CMCR:

The Center for Advanced Marine Core Research

GPTS:

Geomagnetic polarity time scale

CBD:

Citrate–bicarbonate–dithionite

VGP:

Virtual geomagnetic pole

References

Download references

Acknowledgements

We thank two anonymous reviewers for critical comments. We acknowledge Drs. Tatsuo Nozaki and Junichiro Ohta for sharing the compilation of seawater 187Os/188Os and stimulating discussion, Erika Tanaka and Kazuhide Mimura for information on the chemical composition of LL44-GPC3. YU thanks Aguri Irisawa for the help in the laboratory. Part of this study was performed under the cooperative research program of CMCR, Kochi University 15A022 and 15B019. Paleoposition of the site was calculated using GPlates (Boyden et al. 2011) with the rotation model of Matthews et al. (2016). Additional file 1 was created using GMT5 (Wessel et al. 2013). Additional file 2 was created using MagePlot/P (ver. 1.1; Hatakeyama 2018).

Funding

This work was supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant numbers JP17H01361 and JP17H04855.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Contributions

YU and TY contributed to conceptualization. YU conducted chemical digestion analyses, wrote the original draft. TY conducted magnetic analyses, reviewed and edited the draft. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Yoichi Usui.

Ethics declarations

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Not applicable.

Consent for publication

Not applicable.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Additional information

Publisher's Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Supplementary Information

Additional file 1

Location and backtrack of the site. (Top) Location and backtrack path of Minamitorishima Island at 5 Myr intervals. The backtrack path was calculated using GPlates (Boyden et al. 2011) with the rotation model of Matthews et al. (2016). (Bottom) Detailed locations of the core sites.

Additional file 2

Representative orthogonal vector plots for the natural remanences. (a) Normal polarity sample. (b) Reversed polarity sample. (c-e) Samples whose polarities were indeterminate (see text for discussion). Solid circles show the horizontal projection, and open circles show the vertical projection. Colored markers show steps used for PCA analyses. Insets show decay of remanence intensity.

Additional file 3

GPTS correlation models. Possible correlations of paleomagnetic data to GPTS (Ogg, 2012).

Additional file 4

Cenozoic fish debris accumulation flux estimated for LL44-GPC3 in the central North Pacific. Fish debris accumulation rate estimates for LL44-GPC3. Data are from Kyte et al. (1993). P2O5 content was converted to fish debris content assuming that P2O5 is exclusively in fish debris at 30 wt.%.

Rights and permissions

Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Usui, Y., Yamazaki, T. Magnetostratigraphic evidence for post-depositional distortion of osmium isotopic records in pelagic clay and its implications for mineral flux estimates. Earth Planets Space 73, 2 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40623-020-01338-4

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s40623-020-01338-4

Keywords

  • Deep-sea sediments
  • Chronology
  • Eocene
  • Oligocene
  • Diagenesis
  • Bioturbation
  • Eolian dust
  • Rare-earth elements